Why Everyone Who Loves Comics Should Read Amethyst

October 26, 2010 by  
Filed under Blog

Not the article’s true title, but in it you will discover Why Everyone Who Loves Comics Should Read Amethyst. At least a few of the reasons.

I try to grab copies from the quarter bins at every comic con I attend so I can give them to friends. One of the finest examples ever of why comics are great. It’s not just a really solidly-constructed story written with panache and enthusiasm, it also features some of what I like to call “pure comics”.

Don’t believe me? Check out this amazing page from the original maxi-series drawn by Ernie Colón:

I’ve talked with Dan Mishkin about this particular page. He said that Ernie would constantly provide him with challenges in word balloon placement. You see, back then the writers did what’s called “balloon spotting”; figuring out where the word balloons were to go on the penciled art.

Let’s look at the reading direction the balloons take with an Indiana Jones-style tracking line:

Wow, all over the place! But I’ll bet you that you were able to read the page just fine without me pointing that out to you. Here’s where the magic of pure comics happens. Look what the combo of Ernie’s layout with Mishkin’s balloon spotting resulted in:

Panel two’s dialogue bleeds over into panel three, and there is responding dialogue back in panel two again! In other words, Panel two’s moment gets used twice in the narrative. But best of all, the character Granch is being rooted to the ground in panel three by Citrina’s spell, but that’s also part of panel five when Citrina is sitting defeated in her chair. So panel three also does double-duty as panel five!

Yet we read it with ease. That’s probably the most exciting aspect of all. They pulled it together so as not to let inventive paneling and layout distract us from the narrative.

Why is this pure comics? Because no other storytelling medium could pull this off.

And the original Amethyst, Princess of Gemworld maxi-series is full to the lid with these kinds of storytelling moments. It’s more than just a well-crafted piece of fiction–it’s a process nerd’s dream come true, and a worthy piece of comics to study.

I still maintain that Colón can’t possibly be from this planet. He’s that inventive. Or maybe he’s come back from the future to show all of us neanderthal cartoonists how to do it right. 

Related Posts SliderMore Like This
Comics Are Great! 22 – World, Character, Theme
It's an episode packed with great discussion on breaking down a story into comics form with guests Jake Parker and ...
More...
Thunder Punch Daily 25 – That Darned App
Today I share a brief review of the Marvel iPhone App and how the reading experience is a violation of ...
More...
Comics Are Great! 74 – Every Moment is the Moment of Truth with Thien Pham
Mini-Comics, Sumo, Tumblr Comics, Thien Pham, and more! httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-5uYdsO0jI This time we discover that Sumo wrestling can be a metaphor for the ...
More...
Talking with Sumo's Thien Pham on today's Comics Are Great! live showJoin us live at 12:30pm ET at http://comicsaregreat.tv+thien pham is ...
More...
This hit home for me
Something I've been struggling with a lot over the last couple of years, and helps reinforce some of my own ...
More...
The Value of Silence
http://www.jmdematteis.com/2013/01/the-value-of-silence.htmlJ.M. DeMatteis blogs about his experience writing Spectacular Spider-Man #200 and a moment where he came face-to-face with the moment ...
More...
http://leanintoart.com/blog/2013/1/7/lia-cast-67-limbering-up-for-the-new-year.htmlNow that we've reflections and plans for 2013, there's nothing for it but to dive in and complete those goals, ...
More...
Comics Are Great! 69 – Talking Drama with Raina Telgemeier
Drama! Smile! Baby-Sitters Club! Raina Telgemeier! httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rO0bjO1XETI We close out the 2012 broadcast schedule with a special event! I'm joined by guest ...
More...
Comics Are Great! 68 – Watson and Holmes
Sherlock Holmes, Rick Leonardi, Brandon Perlow, Paul Mendoza, and more! httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P89-0ftkE2s This time we talk with the team behind the new Watson ...
More...
Comics are a strange medium. Everything is "happening" on the page at the same time in the sense that there's ...
More...
Comics Are Great! 22 – World, Character, Theme
Thunder Punch Daily 25 – That Darned App
Comics Are Great! 74 – Every Moment is
Talking with Sumo's Thien Pham on today's Comics
This hit home for me
The Value of Silence
The benefits of warm up sketches/activities
Comics Are Great! 69 – Talking Drama with
Comics Are Great! 68 – Watson and Holmes
The Funny Way Time Works in Comics

Comments are closed.